• Register
  • TOS
  • Privacy
  • @NeoGAF
  • Like

Faddy
Member
(04-21-2017, 04:41 PM)
Faddy's Avatar

Originally Posted by Sorian

One of these things is not like the others.



I don't think anyone cared about the joke part of the reads list. But sure, if Lifeline could clarify, that would be great, were you counting fat in this as well?

I included fat4all

You even bolded "everyone" in your post. Unless the definition of everyone has changed...
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 04:44 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Faddy

I included fat4all

You even bolded "everyone" in your post. Unless the definition of everyone has changed...

Yes, you included fat4all after you had a heavy reaction to me pointing at you and you needed a bigger list to hide around in. Let's not forget 15 minutes ago where you were whining like this:

Originally Posted by Faddy

Don't try and implicate me as scum. Lifeline's post clearly shows evidence for you and acorn being a scum team. Stop trying to muddy the waters with your convoluted logic.

Acorn I found out what is off with you, no one is calling you acorn!

Something something pot, something something kettle, something something convoluted logic.
Natiko
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:07 PM)
Natiko's Avatar

Originally Posted by acohrs

Some observations so far despite the game being on P4 only.

Sorian - already solving and leading discussion. From the few games that I've played with Sorian, this is inline with how he play as a townie, so leaning town on him for now.

Faddy - already being quite chatty and solving in his own special way, NAI more just Faddy being Faddy. Having never played with Faddy as scum, going to lean on Faddy as towny for now.

That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more

fat4all - funnest and most awesome pupper in this thread, gets an appreciation pupper for GIF effort and making me smile

Did you play in DR3? I honestly don't remember. I will say though that in DR3 Faddy was a neutral and his play was more aggressive there then it had been in Quarantine. Seeing him be more aggressive yet again concerns me as it doesn't quite line up with what I remember from town Faddy.
Faddy
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:10 PM)
Faddy's Avatar

Originally Posted by Natiko

Did you play in DR3? I honestly don't remember. I will say though that in DR3 Faddy was a neutral and his play was more aggressive there then it had been in Quarantine. Seeing him be more aggressive yet again concerns me as it doesn't quite line up with what I remember from town Faddy.

And my aggressive play in Gafia?

Another strange omission.
Dr. Worm
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:12 PM)
Dr. Worm's Avatar
As someone who isn't familiar with Faddy's prior play, it doesn't appear... Conservative, I guess? The impression I got was that he was reaching a bit in looking for a scumtell.

I do agree with him that Lifeline is probably innocent, though.
*Splinter
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:22 PM)
*Splinter's Avatar

Originally Posted by Faddy

And my aggressive play in Gafia?

Another strange omission.

Is it really that strange for someone to remember a couple of your past performances without being intimately familiar with all of them?
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 05:24 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lifeline

If acnhors is lynched and is Batfam, then it confirms everyone on his list is batfam too. idk, that's how i see it.

This is strange logic.

OK, gonna pull a random vote out.

Vote: SexyFish
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:24 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Faddy

And my aggressive play in Gafia?

Another strange omission.

You didn't really come hot out the gate in gafia if I remember right. Also, this:

Originally Posted by *Splinter

Is it really that strange for someone to remember a couple of your past performances without being intimately familiar with all of them?

acohrs
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:25 PM)
acohrs's Avatar

Originally Posted by Natiko

Did you play in DR3? I honestly don't remember. I will say though that in DR3 Faddy was a neutral and his play was more aggressive there then it had been in Quarantine. Seeing him be more aggressive yet again concerns me as it doesn't quite line up with what I remember from town Faddy.

Did not play DR3 and didn't read it. Faddy is playing similarly to how he played in Gafia 3 where he was town.
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:25 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Timeaisis

This is strange logic.

OK, gonna pull a random vote out.

Vote: SexyFish

Nothing to say about current events?
Faddy
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:26 PM)
Faddy's Avatar

Originally Posted by *Splinter

Is it really that strange for someone to remember a couple of your past performances without being intimately familiar with all of them?

When you are trying to make an argument about how my aggressive play is troubling I think getting my only 3 games right (and Natiko played in all of them) isn't too much to ask.

The whole premise of his argument is wrong anyway since I was neutral in both DR3 and Quarantine. So yeah I think I am justified in pointing it out.
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 05:30 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by Sorian

Nothing to say about current events?

Still reading, but seems like we're centered around ancors, lifeline, you and faddy. Some of it seems...unnatural?
acohrs
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:32 PM)
acohrs's Avatar
Please, just call me acorns
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
(04-21-2017, 05:36 PM)
Terrabyte20xx's Avatar
Reporting In.
First, I think some people are starting to rely on meta too much. Just because someone is playing similar to a game doesn't mean they are the same alignment. I can't tell you how many times scum me has died for a post that town me made or vice versa. It helps when it comes to checking consistency but if someone is acting differently there can be plenty of reasons besides alignment change.


Moving on:

VOTE: Lifeline.
Fireblend
No Member
(04-21-2017, 05:39 PM)
Fireblend's Avatar
Time avoiding the entire convo and just checking in with a random vote seems odd.

And I still feel like much of the conversation feels scripted and forced. And somewhat agree with Terra, I have never really been a fan of "X played like this before so _____________" arguments. Don't want to discourage conversation, just that for someone who pays little mind to specific personal behaviors I find those posts to be of little value. Opinions and all.
Lifeline
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:42 PM)
Lifeline's Avatar
Like I said, I have no idea what I'm doing.

UNVOTE: achors.
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:44 PM)
Sorian's Avatar
I'm sure someone in the conversation is super scripted, Verelios or Faddy imo but ignoring that, I feel like a lot of people are calling the convo unnatural with no substance past that. Fireblend at least pointed out me and Vere specifically and exactly what felt wrong but Time, for example, just calls it unnatural (after a prod).
Dr. Worm
Member
(04-21-2017, 05:49 PM)
Dr. Worm's Avatar
The acohrs read list is strange for this point in the game, to be fair. Coupled with Lifeline's attempt, I can see how it appears manufactured - not on a per-post basis, but taken together.
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 05:52 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by Sorian

I'm sure someone in the conversation is super scripted, Verelios or Faddy imo but ignoring that, I feel like a lot of people are calling the convo unnatural with no substance past that. Fireblend at least pointed out me and Vere specifically and exactly what felt wrong but Time, for example, just calls it unnatural (after a prod).

Well I did say I was still reading, did I not? If you prod me, I will respond with my thoughts at first blush in order to remain active in the conversation, even if those thoughts are off base or just a feeling. That's what I got.

I'm not going to able to do a mega analysis of every post at present.
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 05:53 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by Dr. Worm

The acohrs read list is strange for this point in the game, to be fair. Coupled with Lifeline's attempt, I can see how it appears manufactured - not on a per-post basis, but taken together.

Yup, my thoughts exactly.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
(04-21-2017, 06:01 PM)
Terrabyte20xx's Avatar
These stuck out me:

Originally Posted by Lifeline

Hmmm. Seems suspicious. I'm gonna go with Sorian and acohrs being Batfam.

VOTE: acohrs

No idea what i'm doing

The post he is referring to is if achorms mention his lean town for Sorian and Faddy. Yet he only posits the connection of achors and Sorian.

Shortly:

Originally Posted by Faddy

By the way I am strongly believe Lifeline is not scum.


Just some food for thought.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
(04-21-2017, 06:04 PM)
Terrabyte20xx's Avatar
Man I want to edit that post badly, the fat fingers are killing me.
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:05 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Timeaisis

Well I did say I was still reading, did I not? If you prod me, I will respond with my thoughts at first blush in order to remain active in the conversation, even if those thoughts are off base or just a feeling. That's what I got.

I'm not going to able to do a mega analysis of every post at present.

Sure, I'm just watching you intently sice I plopped my opener vote on you and I've seen no real reason to remove it, plus some meh feeling at you checking in last night but not playing at all until today.

Originally Posted by Terrabyte20xx

These stuck out me:

The post he is referring to is if achorms mention his lean town for Sorian and Faddy. Yet he only posits the connection of achors and Sorian.

Shortly:




Just some food for thought.

My initial gut is that Lifeline was probably town too. I doubt scum goes all in that quick but he has since backed down with no real reasoning which is where I actually see issue.
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 06:09 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by Sorian

Sure, I'm just watching you intently sice I plopped my opener vote on you and I've seen no real reason to remove it, plus some meh feeling at you checking in last night but not playing at all until today.

Fair enough. I was busy when the game started and it wasn't until like 10pm by the time I got to the thread. Just wanted to say hello to show I didn't forget about the game. I think you are overanylzing the timing but that's fine. I'm here now.
AbsolutBro
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:17 PM)
AbsolutBro's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lifeline

Like I said, I have no idea what I'm doing.

posting from mobile and I have a meeting in 10, but don't worry about this. Seriously. Early in the game it's mostly just feeling people out and waiting and seeing. It's very rare to get definitive direction D1. Don't get discouraged!

I will get more in after this meeting.
Fireblend
No Member
(04-21-2017, 06:23 PM)
Fireblend's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lifeline

Like I said, I have no idea what I'm doing.

UNVOTE: achors.

If anything this is more problematic than your initial thinking. Did you feel threatened by the one vote on you?
SexyFish
wakes up from a Murphy bed bothered by nemesis Chow every f'n day
(04-21-2017, 06:25 PM)
SexyFish's Avatar

Originally Posted by Timeaisis

This is strange logic.

OK, gonna pull a random vote out.

Vote: SexyFish

Curse you, random chance.
Natiko
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:28 PM)
Natiko's Avatar

Originally Posted by Faddy

And my aggressive play in Gafia?

Another strange omission.

Gafia 3, the game where I died N1? Excuse me for not remembering it quite as well lol

Originally Posted by Faddy

When you are trying to make an argument about how my aggressive play is troubling I think getting my only 3 games right (and Natiko played in all of them) isn't too much to ask.

The whole premise of his argument is wrong anyway since I was neutral in both DR3 and Quarantine. So yeah I think I am justified in pointing it out.

You were neutral in Quarantine too? I thought it was fran, acorn, melon, and doggo as the neutral team.
franconp
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:34 PM)
franconp's Avatar

Originally Posted by Natiko

Gafia 3, the game where I died N1? Excuse me for not remembering it quite as well lol

You were neutral in Quarantine too? I thought it was fran, acorn, melon, and doggo as the neutral team.

We weren't neutrals!!!

There were 2 neutral teams.
Natiko
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:38 PM)
Natiko's Avatar
Quarantine is like a fever dream at this point. What a crazy little game. I'll let the point rest for now, it somehow turned into Faddy getting upset when I was more questioning acorn's logic. That guy's always scum so I like to keep an eye on him.
Kalor
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:39 PM)
Kalor's Avatar

Originally Posted by Fireblend

If anything this is more problematic than your initial thinking. Did you feel threatened by the one vote on you?

New players do tend to feel threatened by one vote. Either that or that they're going down the wrong road.

I do agree that Acohrs read list feels odd but I'm split on what it indicates. It could be a town member just trying to be active with a read list or scum trying to get points by saying that other people are town.
Natiko
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:46 PM)
Natiko's Avatar
There are still some people that haven't checked in st all. That brothers me.

Originally Posted by StarSketch

Hello

Originally Posted by StarSketch

It's ok, I didn't see that rule my first game. and I edited twice :P Damn my tendency to retroactively fix typos!

This bothers me more though.

VOTE: StarSketch
Fireblend
No Member
(04-21-2017, 06:52 PM)
Fireblend's Avatar

Originally Posted by Kalor

New players do tend to feel threatened by one vote. Either that or that they're going down the wrong road.

Dunno why you felt the need to respond to that post of mine in behalf of Lifeline :P Life might have removed that vote due to that or something else, yes.

Originally Posted by Kalor

I do agree that Acohrs read list feels odd but I'm split on what it indicates. It could be a town member just trying to be active with a read list or scum trying to get points by saying that other people are town.

Hmmm, yes, indeed, people might be scum or town. Good observation.
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:53 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Natiko

There are still some people that haven't checked in st all. That brothers me.



This bothers me more though.

VOTE: StarSketch

Star will have to be scum at some point I'm sure but this feels like such a wasted vote and borders on lazy depending on how well you know Star (I know you at least played with her in DR3). Lack of activity is literally her MO.
*Splinter
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:54 PM)
*Splinter's Avatar

Originally Posted by Kalor

New players do tend to feel threatened by one vote. Either that or that they're going down the wrong road.

I do agree that Acohrs read list feels odd but I'm split on what it indicates. It could be a town member just trying to be active with a read list or scum trying to get points by saying that other people are town.

I think that's a vote-worthy defense

VOTE: Kalor
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:54 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by Fireblend

Dunno why you felt the need to respond to that post of mine in behalf of Lifeline :P Life might have removed that vote due to that or something else, yes.


Hmmm, yes, indeed, people might be scum or town. Good observation.

Kalor continues to be super wishy washy, Fire continues to cut through bullshit. Shame on the first, kudos for the second.
Kalor
Member
(04-21-2017, 06:59 PM)
Kalor's Avatar

Originally Posted by *Splinter

I think that's a vote-worthy defense

VOTE: Kalor

I realised it could be construed as a defense when I was typing it but Lifeline was hardly going to come back and say that they felt threatened by the single vote. Even if I was scum I would leave them to talk for themselves. There's no point defending teammates on the first day since it just brings suspicion on you.
Timeaisis
(04-21-2017, 07:01 PM)
Timeaisis's Avatar

Originally Posted by SexyFish

Curse you, random chance.

Got any thoughts on stuff?
Fireblend
No Member
(04-21-2017, 07:32 PM)
Fireblend's Avatar

Originally Posted by Kalor

I realised it could be construed as a defense when I was typing it but Lifeline was hardly going to come back and say that they felt threatened by the single vote. Even if I was scum I would leave them to talk for themselves. There's no point defending teammates on the first day since it just brings suspicion on you.

So why, if even as scum you would have let them speak for themselves, did you not let them do so here?
StarSketch
Member
(04-21-2017, 07:42 PM)
StarSketch's Avatar

Originally Posted by Natiko

There are still some people that haven't checked in st all. That brothers me.



This bothers me more though.

VOTE: StarSketch

Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 07:48 PM)
Sorian's Avatar
Kalor tripping on words left and right
Kalor
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:04 PM)
Kalor's Avatar

Originally Posted by Fireblend

So why, if even as scum you would have let them speak for themselves, did you not let them do so here?

I didn't write that post intending to speak for them. I saw your post and thought I would at least mention why people have unvoted after getting voted themselves in the past. I also hadn't posted since the start of the day and didn't have much to say about anything else going on so it gave me something to post about.
AbsolutBro
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:16 PM)
AbsolutBro's Avatar
Okay, rereading and putting down thoughts:

@Fat4all - sorry if I seemed actually bothered by the avatar or anything, it was meant as an offhand joke :P

@Sorian - It is always sort of curious how you react to people who talk about ("defend") you to other players. I have seen it in several games now. It is like you see even a single explanatory comment as trying to score Sorian-points or something. Weird.

@acohrs - (post 161) I am just curious, if you were still typing your post, why have the "That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more"? You're typing, not talking. Not a #scumtell or anythin, just curious.

@'batfam' (the term) - please let's not make this a thing. It's not a thing.

@Faddy's 'dont implicate me' post - I thought it was pretty clearly a joke? I mean "clearly shows evidence"? On D1? I am doubt he is serious.

@rng votes - plz no

Guess that's it? Also I am leaving work shortly. Should/might be around later this evening and tomorrow.
Faddy
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:38 PM)
Faddy's Avatar

Originally Posted by AbsolutBro

Okay, rereading and putting down thoughts:

@Fat4all - sorry if I seemed actually bothered by the avatar or anything, it was meant as an offhand joke :P

@Sorian - It is always sort of curious how you react to people who talk about ("defend") you to other players. I have seen it in several games now. It is like you see even a single explanatory comment as trying to score Sorian-points or something. Weird.

@acohrs - (post 161) I am just curious, if you were still typing your post, why have the "That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more"? You're typing, not talking. Not a #scumtell or anythin, just curious.

@'batfam' (the term) - please let's not make this a thing. It's not a thing.

@Faddy's 'dont implicate me' post - I thought it was pretty clearly a joke? I mean "clearly shows evidence"? On D1? I am doubt he is serious.

@rng votes - plz no

Guess that's it? Also I am leaving work shortly. Should/might be around later this evening and tomorrow.

What am I even reading here?

Also batfam is now canon.
Verelios
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:42 PM)
Verelios's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lifeline

Like I said, I have no idea what I'm doing.

UNVOTE: achors.

You didn't explain why you unvoted Acohrs, so I'm going to shoot out some hypotheses and you can hit them down or let them up. Were you not entirely sure about your read direction, kind of unsure as time went by, or as Kalor mentioned, was it a reaction towards getting heat (vote/attention) on you?

Originally Posted by Kalor

I didn't write that post intending to speak for them. I saw your post and thought I would at least mention why people have unvoted after getting voted themselves in the past. I also hadn't posted since the start of the day and didn't have much to say about anything else going on so it gave me something to post about.

Usually, when someone unvotes as a reaction to town pressure or a vote on them, I'm more likely to believe their initial vote was just fluffed up activity to seem town and not a vote with much thought behind it. Here, I'm okay with giving the benefit of doubt since they're new, but for others, not so much.
acohrs
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:47 PM)
acohrs's Avatar
[QUOTE=AbsolutBro;234414831]
@acohrs - (post 161) I am just curious, if you were still typing your post, why have the "That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more"? You're typing, not talking. Not a #scumtell or anythin, just curious.
/QUOTE]

dunno, felt like writing it to be a bit offbeat. Did you like it?
AbsolutBro
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:49 PM)
AbsolutBro's Avatar

Originally Posted by Faddy

What am I even reading here?

I used "guess that's it" cause I was at the end of a thead reread. I didn't continue actual game thoughts.

Acohrs basically did
1
2
That's it
Oh yeah
3

Which I thought was weird. Looking back at it now, it was probably to separate actual game thoughts (1 and 2) from a joke read (3)?
AbsolutBro
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:51 PM)
AbsolutBro's Avatar

Originally Posted by acohrs

Originally Posted by AbsolutBro

@acohrs - (post 161) I am just curious, if you were still typing your post, why have the "That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more"? You're typing, not talking. Not a #scumtell or anythin, just curious.

dunno, felt like writing it to be a bit offbeat. Did you like it?

You have to live with the shame of the broken quote.

Fair enough. Some people type stream of consciousness same as some people speak that way. Unless I'm running out the door (or on mobile) I usually try to go watch my posts since I can't edit.
Faddy
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:53 PM)
Faddy's Avatar

Originally Posted by AbsolutBro

I used "guess that's it" cause I was at the end of a thead reread. I didn't continue actual game thoughts.

Acohrs basically did
1
2
That's it
Oh yeah
3

Which I thought was weird. Looking back at it now, it was probably to separate actual game thoughts (1 and 2) from a joke read (3)?

But what if you had guessed wrong and you had more thoughts?
Sorian
Member
(04-21-2017, 08:53 PM)
Sorian's Avatar

Originally Posted by AbsolutBro

Okay, rereading and putting down thoughts:

@Fat4all - sorry if I seemed actually bothered by the avatar or anything, it was meant as an offhand joke :P

@Sorian - It is always sort of curious how you react to people who talk about ("defend") you to other players. I have seen it in several games now. It is like you see even a single explanatory comment as trying to score Sorian-points or something. Weird.

@acohrs - (post 161) I am just curious, if you were still typing your post, why have the "That's all I have for now folks! Oh, except for one more"? You're typing, not talking. Not a #scumtell or anythin, just curious.

@'batfam' (the term) - please let's not make this a thing. It's not a thing.

@Faddy's 'dont implicate me' post - I thought it was pretty clearly a joke? I mean "clearly shows evidence"? On D1? I am doubt he is serious.

@rng votes - plz no

Guess that's it? Also I am leaving work shortly. Should/might be around later this evening and tomorrow.

I'm confused what I'm reading here. Not much of it really had to do with the game. I mean, even my section is just something you wanted to point out about my overall character but with no meaning behind it. Faddy's was probably the only semi serious section.

Thread Tools