Originally Posted by Dr.Hadji
Just finished my first dungeon, Va Ruta..........
You guys are my Zelda fam but those of you calling these the worst Zelda dungeons.... ya brain broke homies. I know there are a lot of different dungeon flavors to choose from and BotW's may not be to your particular liking so I'm interesting in hearing the particulars of the critique.
I'll through my hat into the ring. That was one of the cleanest dungeons in Zelda history. Easy. Complexity wise, easily more in depth than "before the word twist" starting Zelda dungeons.
Know this comment is old, but I felt compelled to answer.
Overall, I am mixed about the dungeons. There are cleverly made and are a very different take on the dungeon system, especially the map. Overall, they're some of the most creative dungeons in the series (the ones I did, I only did two so far). I also like how they fit narratively within the story.
However, they're too short in my opinion. They feel like glorified shines in a way. Which would be fine if the dungeons isn't a big deal to those who like Zelda. To me, this hurts the experience since I love the 3D dungeons and no other game comes close to giving me the experience, especially Twilight Prince and Skyward Sword which have some of the best dungeons in the series. You can't even revisited these dungeons once you beat them
Overall, I like the puzzle aspect of the dungeons and I would love if they expand it. But, they come off on the lackluster side for me.